Powered by People


Articles and Legal News

Please note all of our news and articles are for general information purposes only and do not constitute legal advice. For advice tailored to your circumstances please contact your Saunders & Co lawyer. As well as providing regular news updates on the feed adjacent, we also provide a personalised news email service. To choose what news we send you, click here.

The Shape of Sweet Victory – for Whittakers

Do you recognise a Whittaker’s SANTE® bar when you see it?  If you do, you know what you are buying.  After successfully defeating a third party opposition to their application, Whittaker’s SANTE® bar recently became the 231st shape on the New Zealand Register of Trade Marks.

What is a Shape trade mark? 

A trade mark is a sign that is capable of distinguishing the goods of one trader from those of another[1].  It is designed to function as a “badge of origin”.

What these legal tests mean in practical terms is that when you see a trade mark, you know who has made that product.  Sometimes the shape of the packaging, or even of the product itself, is sufficiently distinctive that consumers recognise the product as coming from one particular manufacturer.

You can probably recognise these products by their shapes:

3 shapesv2

There are also a number of alcoholic beverages that consumers could locate and select based solely on the shape of their bottles.

Whittaker’s Application

Whittaker’s has sold its SANTE® bar chocolate since the early 1950s.  Originally these were sold as unwrapped bars.  In 2001, they started selling a wrapped version.  The wrapping was designed to “hug” the shape of the bar, so that consumers would still recognise it.

The shape was graphically represented in the application in a series of views:

shape

Whittaker’s were not seeking to gain a monopoly over the idea of a chocolate stick or finger, but the specific shape shown in these drawings.

The application was eventually accepted by IPONZ, but was opposed by a rival confectioner.

Evidence was presented including relating to market share, methods of promotion and volumes of sales.  This evidence was found to be sufficient to meet the required level of acquired distinctiveness.

Whittaker’s now have an enforceable monopoly in their distinctive chocolate bar shape.

Points to remember: 

  • The distinctive shape of a product may be registered as a shape trade mark
  • It may be necessary to prepare and file evidence establishing that distinctiveness has been acquired through use in order to succeed
  • Regular IP Audits will help you identify your business’s distinctive trade marks, and develop a strategy for protecting these – contact us today.

[1] Paraphased from s 5 Trade Marks Act 2002

"Through this time we have required the services of the firm for business, personal, and litigation purposes. We have never felt a moment's hesitation in remaining with the firm, and expect to continue a long and prosperous relationship with Saunders & Co. into the future."

Colin and Julie Erickson, Cube Developments Limited

"Excellent law firm to deal with. Excellent communication and service."

Carmel Kokshoorn, Property Owner

"Thanks Hornby Law for your professional and helpful advice. It is nice when everything runs smoothly."

Barry and Natalie Gibb

"We have found them reliable, timely and professional. They have added value to our business by being effective and decisive. Their friendly manner whilst conducting business means that we have felt comfortable seeking their advice no matter how major or minor the query may be. We would have no hesitation in recommending Saunders & Co to family, friends and business associates."

Cymon and Angela Allfrey, Cymon Allfrey Architects Ltd

"Very prompt and efficient service. I have been very well informed and kept up to date on matters. To be recommended. Thank you."

Suzanne Henderson, Property

"The professional and friendly service provided by Jenni Hunter allowed us to buy our first home without fuss stress or delays, absolutely seamless! Amenable, and more importantly always accessible to clarify and assist, Jenni proved you can get an exclusive personal service without paying Auckland barrister prices."

James Craig, Home Buyer

"Always happy with service and professionalism at Hornby Law. Never had any reason or desire to change firms; friendly, welcoming, professional and easy to do business with."

Frans and Rose-Marie van Zoggel

"Thank you Ria and your team for the excellent work in completing the sale on such a short turnaround, that's why I always use Saunders & Co."

Ashley Patten, Property Owner

"I have worked with Saunders & Co on both a professional and personal basis for over 10 years. I have always found their service and quality of legal advice to be first rate. Attention to detail and timeliness is important to our business, and Saunders & Co have always performed in these critical areas."

Ian McNabb, Ngai Tahu Property Limited